Some marketers still failing the 'appeal of real' test

Department of Consumer Protection finds evidence of frozen seafood package labels that inaccurately reflect the product weight. The difference was made up by ice.

Brand consultants have been preaching for some time that above all, a product has to be trustworthy to remain in shoppers’ consideration set. Brands that are authentic, in both product and packaging, have the best chance of retaining loyal consumers.

But as the Harford Courant reports, some branding teams still aren’t heeding the message. The newspaper quotes the Department of Consumer Protection (DCP) as saying that half of 52 frozen seafood products it inspected failed its packaging truth test. Jerry Farrell Jr., DCP commissioner, says packages that failed the test contained less product in weight than what was reported on the label and that excess ice made up the weight difference.

The 26 products that failed the review have been pulled from store shelves, and the brand owners might face fines.

It’s worth considering what James Gilmore and B. Joseph Pine state in their book “Authenticity: What Consumers Really Want.” Consumers are drawn to the “appeal of real.” That includes branding communication that accurately reflects what’s inside the package.

Need help with your packaging project?
We’ve done the legwork to identify and vet experienced packaging and processing consultants you can contact directly for your next project. Decades of combined experience in packaging line engineering, machinery selection, package and materials development, and food processing operations.
See your advisor options now.
Need help with your packaging project?
Don't miss Packaging Recycling Summit 2026
Where innovation meets sustainability. Join the leading forum for packaging recycling professionals, featuring cutting-edge solutions, expert insights, and the connections you need to advance the circular economy. Secure your spot today.
Discover More
Don't miss Packaging Recycling Summit 2026