Discover your next big idea at PACK EXPO Las Vegas this September
Experience a breakthrough in packaging & processing and transform your business with solutions from 2,300 suppliers spanning all industries.
REGISTER NOW & SAVE

FDA and appellate court spar over expiration dates

If you’re in the business of buying and reselling bottles of salad dressing, can you change the best-if-used-by dates before you resell them? FDA said no but a Chicago court disagreed.

Eric_Greenberg
Eric_Greenberg

A recent article on Web site Slate.com suggested that consumers ignore expiration dates on labels and use their own sense to determine food’s freshness. It so happens an appellate court took up such issues over a year ago, and, for a change, handed FDA it’s, um, defeat. It’s not every day you see a court decision finding that you can change something on a food label after it’s in commerce and not end up with an illegal, misbranded food, but it happened once last March. 


The federal appellate court in Chicago threw out the conviction of a re-seller of bottled salad dressing for having misbranded the bottles, which he had bought and then resold, for having extended the “best when purchased by” dates on the bottles. US v. Farinella, 08-1839, US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.



FDA produced no evidence that the law contained any prohibition against changing such dates, so the defendant hadn’t violated any specific prohibition, and no evidence that the food product was unwholesome or even unpalatable, so he hadn’t marketed an actually adulterated food. And there was no evidence about what consumers’ understanding was of these label terms, so there wasn’t evidence that the statements were misleading.

Researched List: Engineering Services Firms
Looking for engineering services? Our curated list features 100+ companies specializing in civil, process, structural, and electrical engineering. Many also offer construction, design, and architecture services. Download to access company names, markets served, key services, contact information, and more!
Download Now
Researched List: Engineering Services Firms
Break out of the ordinary: see what’s new in packaging & processing!
At PACK EXPO Las Vegas, you’ll see machinery in action and new tech from 2,300 suppliers, collaborate with experts and explore transformative solutions. Join us this September to experience a breakthrough in packaging and processing.
REGISTER NOW AND SAVE
Break out of the ordinary: see what’s new in packaging & processing!