"If you'd asked me three or four years ago if I considered that PEN or any other material for that matter would take a share of the PET market, I would have said the economics would prevent it," Michael Koch of Krupp Corpoplast (Hamburg, Germany) told the audience at Bev-Pak Americas '95 in April. And what does he think now about PEN and related naphthalate-based resins? "We're right in front of a major breakthrough." Koch then went on to present Krupp's laboratory cost comparison of four different container types, each made from four different materials: with straight PET and with three different naphthalate compositions. Container #1 was a 500-mL single-serve beverage bottle; #2, a 32-oz ketchup bottle; #3, a 1.5-L hot washable, refillable and hot-refillable (HRHF) bottle (described by Koch as "the most innovative application"); and #4, a 1.5-L one-way heat-set hot-fill container. The table shown at right summarizes the key findings of Krupp's test. Worth noting: * Because NDC-based materials show a slightly higher natural stretch ratio, blow molding cycle times came down for all four bottles when NDC was part of the resin composition. * As expected, in all four bottle types, desirable performance characteristics-thermal stability, gas and UV barrier, strength-improved when NDC was part of the composition. * The single-serve container made of 8% PEN blended with 92% PET leads to a slight container cost improvement compared to straight PET because it weighs 5 g less. * When NDC was part of the resin composition at any of the levels studied, both the HRHF container and the one-way hot-fill bottle offered significant cost advantages over PET containers. * The ketchup bottle looks promising at an 8% PEN blend level. "PEN is an interesting candidate in this application," said Koch. The two bottles that most intrigued Koch were the HRHF and the one-way hot-fill, because for both bottles, the use of a naphthalate-based resin reduced container cost per thousand. "I think this could have a considerable impact on the markets for hot-fill, heat-set containers," Koch told his audience. Bev-Pak Americas '95, held April 24-25 in Tarpon Springs, FL, was sponsored by Directions 21 (Sarasota, FL).
Naphthalate-based bottles beckon (sidebar)
What about cost?
Jun 30, 1995
Companies in this article
Machinery Basics
Is your palletizing solution leaving money on the floor?
Discover which palletizing technology—robotic, conventional, or hybrid—will maximize your packaging line efficiency while minimizing long-term costs in this comprehensive analysis.
Read More
Annual Outlook Report: Workforce
Hiring remains a major challenge in packaging, with 78% struggling to fill unskilled roles and 84% lacking experienced workers. As automation grows, companies must rethink hiring and training. Download the full report for key insights.
Download Now