- Contract Packaging
- Leaders in Packaging
Article | July 31, 1995
Corona treating equipment suit settled
Enercon Industries Corp., Menomonee Falls, WI, and German partner Ahlbrandt Systems, Inc. filed suit against Pillar Technolo-gies, Hartland, WI, in 1986 alleging that Pillar infringed on two Ahlbrandt patents involving corona treating equipment, which treats the surfaces of plastic films or metal foils to improve ink adhesion.
Pillar countersued alleging that Enercon's patent was not valid; this suit was stayed pending the outcome of the infringement suit. By the time the infringement case went to trial in July 1993 Ahlbrandt/Enercon had removed one patent from the suit as well as six of the seven claims of the second patent identified as Patent #4. On June 14 the U.S. District Judge for the Eastern District of Wisconsin ruled on the suit ordering that it be dismissed. Having found in favor of Pillar the judge found it unnecessary to decide on Pillar's claims of invalidity of the patent. Pillar says it has "won a resounding decision." Enercon says "the judge rendered a split decision" because while he did indeed find that Pillar hadn't infringed "he did not rule that Enercon's patent or any of its claims was invalid as Pillar had argued." Pillar has motioned the court to rule on the validity issue.
Related Sponsored Content
E-BOOK SPECIAL REPORT
44 Best Package Designs: 2015
Sign up to receive timely updates from our editors and download this e-book of our editors’ selections for most innovative package designs of the past year.