Download Download this free, 150-page Pharmaceutical Serialization Playbook jam-packed with strategies for success and pitfalls to avoid.  Learn more >>
Article |

What packagers want in turnkey projects (sidebar)

Outsourcing not always 'in'
FILED IN:  Applications  > Food  > Dairy

Although 75% of the survey respondents say they outsource at least some turnkey projects the 25% who don't weighed in very vocally with their opinions.

"We don't think it's possible to do a true turnkey" says a senior engineer for a pharmaceutical manufacturer. "No one coming in can really know enough about internal company nuances. They can do a building just fine but not a sophisticated packaging line. That's why Coca-Cola and Anheuser-Busch each have their own fully staffed engineering groups. Outsourcing is just not worth it. You end up paying for the engineering twice by the time you explain it all."

A mechanical engineer for a major national drug company agrees. "We've never outsourced a turnkey project. Corporate-wide we have had modestly disastrous experiences" he reports. "When you say 'turnkey' here people get hives and break out in a rash. I don't ever expect to do one."

Related Sponsored Content

Others have had negative experiences. "We think we are more responsible than a vendor is. The vendor doesn't know and in most cases doesn't care about our needs" says a project engineer for a national personal care product manufacturer. "The larger the vendor the worse they are to deal with. I've seen some real fiascos like when a major Northeast dairy spent millions on a turnkey project and then had to bring in another company to straighten it out."

Other participants had very specific reasons to keep these projects in-house. "If a project has to interface with our systems we like to do it in-house" states a major brewer's plant engineer. "Sometimes turnkey providers don't see the project's long-term view. They want to get done and get gone."

Still this engineer does see some advantages in outsourcing. "Especially for a union plant outsourcing usually means the project is done on time and at an agreed-upon price. When it's done at plant level it's hard to keep to the budget. Add-ons add up."

Plant conditions can be a factor says an engineer at a Midwest food plant. "We have a tough work environment that outside vendors rarely can fully understand. When we do a project in-house we retain familiarity with the equipment and are more aware of the stresses on our equipment."


E-Book Special Report
Total Cost of Ownership
Sign up to receive timely updates from our editors and download this E-Book Special Report to learn how to calculate the true Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) of your packaging machinery.


Don't miss intelligence crucial to your job and business!
Click on any newsletter to view a sample. Enter your email address below to sign up!
Each newsletter ranges in frequency from once per month to a few times per month at most.